AI Creates a Divide in Software Stocks: The Haves and Have Nots
The software industry is currently facing a notable division as advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) reshape market dynamics. Historically, investing in the iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF (IGV) offered broad exposure to reliable software-as-a-service (SaaS) revenue models. However, the landscape has changed, leading to a split among software stocks.
At a macro level, the industry is now divided into two distinct groups: those companies providing infrastructure that supports AI workflows and those relying on legacy application software that is encountering pricing pressures. Firms that own foundational enterprise databases, multi-cloud infrastructures, and specialized data pipelines are seeing an increase in their market share.
Market Reading & Resources
Sponsor funding complete. Trade on.
In contrast, traditional SaaS providers are grappling with the unintended consequences of AI agents, which, while designed to enhance workforce efficiency, can reduce the number of paid user seats that enterprise clients require. This shift poses a significant challenge for companies that depend on a high volume of user subscriptions.
Among the top holdings in the IGV ETF, Oracle (ORCL) stands out as a legacy company that is successfully transforming its business model. Once viewed as a slow-growing database provider, Oracle has evolved into a key player in multi-cloud infrastructure. By forming direct partnerships with major cloud service providers and offering specialized environments for heavy AI workloads, Oracle is capturing a more stable segment of corporate spending. This transition from traditional software licensing to essential cloud database services has granted Oracle greater pricing power and cash-flow visibility compared to many of its application-level competitors.
On the other hand, companies like Salesforce (CRM), which recently saw a significant stock rally, are facing challenges. Salesforce's growth has been bolstered by announcements of automated AI agents, but the company's business model is under pressure. As enterprises deploy these autonomous agents for sales and customer support, the demand for human employee seats diminishes. Until Salesforce can demonstrate that it can monetize its AI capabilities effectively, its growth potential may be limited.
The performance of stocks like Oracle and Salesforce reflects the broader trends within the IGV ETF, which is characterized by a mix of strong and weak performers. For instance, ServiceNow (NOW) shows potential but has experienced significant volatility, indicating that it could face selling pressure in the near future. Similarly, Fortinet (FTNT) has been a volatile stock, suggesting it may also be nearing a peak.
This internal division within the software sector illustrates why holding a diversified software ETF like IGV feels increasingly like a balancing act. Investors now need to assess whether a company's offerings align with the ongoing technological shifts. As a result, stock selection within the IGV ETF may prove more advantageous than simply holding the ETF outright.




